When an appliance breaks down, homeowners face the common dilemma: repair or replace an appliance. This decision depends on several factors, including the item’s age, warranty status, repair costs, and your budget.
Below is a comprehensive guide to help you weigh your options.
Use the table below as a rough guide to estimate whether you should repair or replace. Keep in mind actual costs vary by brand, region, and the extent of damage.
|
Appliance
|
Average Repair Cost
|
Average Replacement Cost
|
Likelihood (%) To Replace Vs. Repair
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Refrigerator
|
$150 – $350*
|
$700 – $2,000+
|
40% Replace, 60% Repair
|
|
Stove/Oven
|
$100 – $300*
|
$600 – $1,500+
|
35% Replace, 65% Repair
|
|
Washing Machine
|
$120 – $350*
|
$400 – $1,000+
|
45% Replace, 55% Repair
|
|
Dryer
|
$100 – $300*
|
$400 – $1,000+
|
30% Replace, 70% Repair
|
|
Dishwasher
|
$100 – $250*
|
$400 – $800+
|
30% Replace, 70% Repair
|
|
Microwave Oven
|
$50 – $150
|
$100 – $400+
|
50% Replace, 50% Repair
|
|
Ice Machine
|
$150 – $300*
|
$500 – $1,500+
|
40% Replace, 60% Repair
|
Below is a general guideline for how long you can expect each appliance to last.
|
Appliance
|
Average Lifespan*
|
|---|---|
|
Refrigerator
|
10 – 15 years
|
|
Stove/Oven
|
10 – 15 years
|
|
Washing Machine
|
8 – 12 years
|
|
Dryer
|
8 – 12 years
|
|
Dishwasher
|
8 – 10 years
|
|
Microwave Oven
|
5 – 10 years
|
|
Ice Machine
|
5 – 10 years
|
Repair
Replace
When deciding to repair or replace an appliance, weigh the repair cost against how many more years you could realistically use the appliance. For instance, if your 12-year-old dishwasher needs a $200 repair, and you can buy a new, more efficient model for $500 on sale, it might be worthwhile to upgrade.
Consider the appliance’s age, cost of repair, cost of replacement, warranty status, availability of parts, and how many times it has needed repairs. Evaluating these factors gives you a clearer picture of whether a repair is worthwhile or if replacing might be more cost-effective in the long run.
Replacing all appliances simultaneously can be convenient if they are all nearing the end of their lifespans or if you want a cohesive, updated look. However, it can also be costly. Evaluate each appliance individually, especially if some have plenty of life left or recent repairs.
Some appliances, like refrigerators or ovens, can surpass 15 years and approach the 20-year mark, especially if well-maintained. Regular appliance maintenance—such as cleaning coils or filters—can help extend their lifespan, but the likelihood diminishes past the average lifespan range.
Older appliances can be reliable if well-maintained but often lag behind newer models in terms of energy efficiency and advanced features. Newer appliances may have better technology and eco-friendly designs. Whether old is “better” depends on performance, reliability, and maintenance records.
There is no one-size-fits-all solution for whether to repair or replace an appliance. It comes down to the appliance’s age, condition, warranty status, and part availability. If you need expert advice or appliance repair services, consider Appliance GrandMasters—especially if you’re in Greenville SC. They can inspect your appliance, provide estimates, and help you make the best decision.
Tip: Regular appliance maintenance can help avoid unexpected breakdowns and extend your appliance’s lifespan—often the most cost-effective strategy in the long run.
Get professional home appliance Repairs, maintenance & Installation now!
Formerly known as Mr. Rogers Appliances, we rebranded our appliance repair company to Appliance GrandMasters in June 2020. Since then, we have focused on developing our brand to be customer-oriented.
Fixing appliances has become a passion for us. We enjoy challenges and we are always studying to become the very best.
We accomplish swift and top-notch service by employing efficient and friendly customer service procedures that guarantee accurate answers and solutions.
Our approach involves the careful selection and comprehensive training for the necessary skills to fulfill our customers’ needs. Through these strategies, we strive to consistently provide exceptional service.